Archie Battersbee dies after UK doctors end life-saving treatment

Archie Battersbee, a 12-year-old boy who had been in a coma for four months, died in a London hospital after doctors ended life-saving treatment his family had been fighting for.

The boy’s mother, Hollie Dance, said her son died at 12.15pm on Saturday, about two hours after the hospital began withdrawing treatment.

British courts had rejected both the family’s efforts to extend treatment and a request to transfer Archie to a hospice, saying neither move was in the child’s best interests.

“I’m the proudest mum in the world,” Ms Dance said as she stood outside the hospital and wept.

“Such a beautiful little boy and he fought until the very end.”

The legal battle is the latest in a series of very public British cases in which parents and doctors have argued over who is best qualified to make decisions about a child’s medical care.

This has sparked a debate about whether there is a more appropriate way to settle such disputes outside of the courts.

Weeks of legal arguments

Archie was found unconscious at his home with a ligature on his head on April 7.

His parents think he may have participated in an online challenge gone wrong.

Doctors concluded that Archie had died of the brainstem shortly after the accident and sought to end the long list of treatments that were keeping him alive, including artificial respiration, drugs to regulate his bodily functions and 24 hour nursing care.

But his family objected, saying Archie had shown signs of life and wouldn’t have wanted them to give up hope.

Hollie Dance, pictured last week, says Archie was “a beautiful little boy”.(Sound system via AP: James Manning)

The disagreement sparked weeks of legal arguments as Archie’s parents sought to force the hospital to continue with life-saving treatments.

Doctors at the Royal London Hospital argued there was no chance of recovery and he should be allowed to die.

The court decides that the boy can die

After a series of courts ruled it was in Archie’s best interests that he be allowed to die, the family sought permission to move him to a hospice.

The hospital said Archie’s condition was so unstable that moving him would hasten his death.

High Court Judge Lucy Theis on Friday dismissed the family’s request, ruling that Archie should remain in hospital while treatment is stopped.

“Their unconditional love and devotion to Archie is a golden thread that runs through this case,” she wrote in her decision.

“I hope now that Archie will have the opportunity to die in peaceful circumstances, with the family that meant so much to him that he clearly does for them.”

The ruling was handed down on Saturday after the UK Court of Appeal and the European Court of Human Rights declined to take up the case.

Family calls boy’s death ‘barbaric’

Archie’s family say his death was anything but peaceful.

Ella Carter, fiancée of Archie’s older brother Tom, said Archie was stable for about two hours after the hospital stopped all medication.

That changed when the fan was turned off, she said.

“He turned completely blue,” she said. “There is absolutely nothing dignified about watching a family member or child suffocate.

“No family should have to go through what we’ve been through. It’s barbaric.”

Mrs. Carter rested her head on Mrs. Dance’s shoulder and sobbed as the two women embraced.

Three women stand with Hollie Dance in front of microphones outside the Royal London Hospital
Hollie Dance, second from left, and her supporters talk to reporters after the death of her son.(Sound system via AP: Aaron Chown)

The hospital expressed its condolences and thanked the doctors and nurses who cared for Archie.

“They provided high quality care with extraordinary compassion for many months in often trying and distressing circumstances,” said Alistair Chesser, chief medical officer at Barts Health NHS Trust, which runs the hospital.

“This tragic case not only affected the family and their caregivers, but touched the hearts of many people across the country.”

When doctors and parents disagree

Legal experts insist that cases like Archie’s are rare.

But some disputes pitting the judgment of doctors against the will of families have been fought out in the public eye, such as the 2017 court battle over Charlie Gard, an infant with a rare genetic condition.

The parents fought unsuccessfully for him to receive experimental treatment before his death.

Under UK law, it is common for the courts to intervene when parents and doctors disagree over a child’s medical treatment.

The best interests of the child take precedence over the right of parents to decide what they think is best.

Call for an inquiry

Ilora Finlay, a professor of palliative medicine at Cardiff University and a member of the House of Lords, said this week she hoped the Conservative government would carry out an independent inquiry into the different ways of dealing with these cases.

Deciding such disputes through an adversarial court process does not help anyone, she said.

“Parents don’t want to go to court. Doctors don’t want to go to court. Managers don’t want to go to court,” Professor Finlay told Times Radio.

“My concern is that these cases are going to court too quickly and too soon, and that we need another way to manage communication between doctors and parents.”

The difficulty for parents is that they are in shock and often want to deny there has been a catastrophic brain injury, Prof Finlay said.

“When there’s a brain injury, often their child looks intact, so their face is just like before,” she said.

“So understanding what happened inside the brain and the amount of injury is something that needs to be sensitively explained to parents, and that takes time.”

Archie’s family have been supported by Christian Concern, which campaigns on end-of-life issues and the role of religion in society.

The group said it was a “privilege” to stand alongside the family.

“The events of the past few weeks raise many important questions, including questions about the definition of death, how these decisions are made and the place of family,” Christian Concern chief executive Andrea Williams said.


Comments are closed.